FAQs What is the best bait for the Goodnature A18 squirrel trap? With the Goodnature Hazelnut Lure now discontinued, most operators use natural peanut butter, hazelnut paste or a similar high-fat, high-aroma bait applied directly into the lure basket. Peanuts and sunflower seeds also work well in cooler months when squirrels are caching food. < All FAQs